Entry No. 26
Physiotherapist, movement specialist and trauma educator, TRE Australia
“Just mix it up, reverse it.”
Also on Amazon Music · RSS feed
In this entry
- Five habits many Pilates teachers inherit, all starting with ‘always’: fixed breath patterns, mouth exhales, core bracing and more
- Why carbon dioxide matters for oxygen delivery, and what nasal breathing and breathing less might offer in a Pilates class
- Focusing on bones rather than muscles, and reframing shaking and trembling during exercise through Richmond’s TRE work
Show notes and timestamps
Welcome to the Pilates Diaries Podcast.
Richmond Heath is a physiotherapist, movement specialist and trauma educator, and the founder of TRE clinical training programs for movement, exercise and body-based professionals in Australia. This is his second appearance on The Pilates Diaries, after Entry No. 06. He taught Pilates more or less full time before moving into TRE and trauma resilience work.
In this conversation Richmond walks through five common faux pas he believes many Pilates instructors have inherited from their teachers: always breathing in or out in a set direction of movement, always breathing out through the mouth, always stabilising the core while moving the periphery, always focusing on the neuromuscular system, and always telling people to control shaking and tremoring. He stresses that none of these is wrong, only limiting when used all the time, and draws on his own experience of chronic back pain, breathwork training and meditation. He also talks about his online TRE course.
Find Richmond Heath
TRE Australia
Resources mentioned in this entry
Kelly McGonigal’s TED talk, How to make stress your friend
Kelly McGonigal’s books, including The Upside of Stress and The Joy of Movement: kellymcgonigal.com/books
Campbell Will, Breath Body Therapy (breathwork training): breathbodytherapy.com
Patrick McKeown, The Oxygen Advantage, book and podcast: oxygenadvantage.com
James Nestor, Breath: The New Science of a Lost Art
Tess Graham, BreatheAbility: breatheability.com
Jakki Tobin on The Pilates Diaries: Entry No. 03
Bonnie Bainbridge Cohen, Body-Mind Centering: bodymindcentering.com
Dr David Berceli, creator of TRE: treglobal.org
Bradford Keeney, Shaking Medicine: The Healing Power of Ecstatic Movement
Dr John Tickell, Laughter, Sex, Vegetables & Fish and Love, Laugh, and Eat
Richmond’s online TRE course: trecourse.com
Timestamps
00:00 Acknowledgement of Country
00:15 Welcome to The Pilates Diaries
00:37 Meet Richmond
12:22 The five faux pas, and number one: always breathing in a set direction
24:43 Faux pas two: always breathing out through the mouth
43:41 A word about Trimio
44:40 Faux pas three: always stabilising the core
52:33 Faux pas four: always focusing on the muscles
1:05:48 Faux pas five: always controlling shaking and tremoring
1:19:15 Thank you, Richmond
Supported by Trimio
Got downtime in your studio?
Got spare hours in your week?
Want your teacher closer to home?
Full transcript
Bruce Hildebrand: In the spirit of respect, The Pilates Diaries Podcast acknowledges the people and elders of the Bunurong people, members of the Kulin Nation, who have traditional connections and responsibilities for the land on which this podcast is produced. This is the Pilates Diaries podcast, stories of the impact of Pilates from the people who live it. I’m Bruce Hildebrand, 20-odd years of teaching, a few studios along the way, a lot of questions I still haven’t answered, and no doubt more on the way. Let’s get into today’s episode. Richmond Heath is a physiotherapist, movement specialist, trauma educator, and the go to TRE trainer here in Australia, as the founder of the TRE clinical training programs for movement exercise and body based professionals. And a huge advocate for all things trauma related, particularly when it comes to unraveling the wonder of your body. Richmond, welcome to the show.
Richmond Heath: Thanks for having me, Bruce. It’s been a while since we did our first interview. Yeah, it’s a couple of years ago now. It’s great
Bruce Hildebrand: to have you back on the Pilates Diaries podcast. Thanks so much for your time as always. Can’t wait to dive into this episode’s wonderful topic that you’ve put together – five common faux pas most Pilates instructors have inherited from their teachers. Can you give us a quick overview of the inspiration that had you reach out and. Want to touch base again with the podcast and get your message out there.
Richmond Heath: The reason I’ve chosen this title and specifically the word faux pas has got to do with the idea of, you know, it’s a slip or a blunder. It’s generally not something we’re doing deliberately and we’re not doing consciously. And the origins of it was that I’ve been attending regular Pilates classes at my local gym with, you know, right people, relatively low level of training, pretty basic Mac classes. And so constantly I’m having experiences of going, gee, we could be doing this better or why are we doing this? So that’s been something over the last year or two. coming out of the things that I’m learning and discovering over the last sort of, 10, 15 years in terms of a trauma informed model of movement and chronic pain and chronic tension. And also the reason I like that title is one of my favourite TED talks, if you haven’t heard it, I highly recommend it, is a woman called Kelly McGonigal who does a talk called How to make stress your friend. And I think it’s like in the top 10 Ted Talks. And what I love about this is she gets up and she starts her Ted Talk with a confession. She basically says, look, for the last 20 years or whatever, I’ve been educating people that, you know, stress is really bad for you. It’s bad for your health, blah, blah, blah. And she says, and I, I need to make a confession. I was wrong. Here’s this study. And she goes on to explain how the study showing that how you perceive stress is the primary determinant of how your body then responds to it. It’s a fascinating tech talk. Go and check it out. But what I loved about it was she wasn’t too ego wasn’t too weak or fractured or, and she was very humble to be able to say, Hey, look, I’ve just discovered something. And with this new bit of information, I realized that what I was doing in the past wasn’t necessarily correct and I could be doing something better. So this is the reason I’ve. I’ve chosen this title, the faux pas, and the reason that we’ve inherited them is because they’re largely a cultural, practice or information that we’ve received from our teachers. And I don’t just mean our Pilates teachers and our elders and our culture. And I also want to start with the acknowledgement that I’ve done all of these. And when I was teaching Pilates, you know, more or less full time for four or five years ago, before I started working in TRE and the trauma resilience field. I did all of these because I was passing on the information that I too had been passed on to in a whole range of fields. And so for me, I think it’s important for us to be able to acknowledge that when we learn improvements, we need to be able to acknowledge that, hey, you know, this isn’t about beating ourselves up about the past or we’ve done it wrong or with bad people, because we’re all joining in the field of trying to empower and help people. But we need to be able to acknowledge where, hey, that’s how it was done in the past. But we need to acknowledge that in order to be able to do things better in the future so that people can get even better results. So that’s the reason for the title. And it’s coming very much out of, I’m not saying, hey, I’ve got this all right and everyone else is wrong. I’ve made all these faux pas because I passed on the information that was passed on to me, just like we all have. But that doesn’t mean that we have to keep passing on this information. It’s not so much that what we’ve done in the past is wrong or bad, but it could be better.
Bruce Hildebrand: I think there’s a hell of a lot in everything you just said, Richmond. It’s always a pleasure to chat with you. unpack this a lot. The first thing that springs to mind is my first contact with the conscious awareness about stress and the distinction between pressure and stress. An amazing guy many years ago across paths with, I think as a 19 year old, Dr. John Tickell, he had authored a book called laughter, sex, vegetables, and fish. And I’ve now visited his website recently and the title of the website is Health, Stress and Longevity. Such a buzzword at the moment. Lots of elements around that and everything Kelly’s talking about as well. Love, Laugh and Eat is another more recent book that he’s published. Recent being in the last 10 or 11 years. John Tickell. Yeah, that was the last thing message that he left with me, which was we’re all exposed to various pressures in our life, but whether we choose to respond with it, with a stress response or to actually deal with it is also wrapped into the message about trauma and how our nervous system is adaptable capable of processing various simple. If we use the technical word stimuli that come and go in our day to day activities, how we learn to deal with those, I think is probably along the lines of what Kelly’s talking about.
Richmond Heath: Yeah, and again, the thing is, if we inherit a certain perspective, that can actually have a really significant impact on possibilities we can experience in relation to that. So for me as a TRE trainee, you know, As a physiotherapist, I was always told well, if the body’s shaking or trembling while we’re doing exercises or Pilates, it’s a sign of weakness, lack of control and fatigue. So we need to stop the exercise and take control. Now, in one sense, that’s true, that it’s moving beyond our capacity to volitionally, Consciously, cognitively direct that movement, but if we only ever follow that, then we miss out on going, hang on, but that shaking or trembling response is a doorway to a much deeper subcortical organic movement response, which can reorganize tension patterns, movement, breathing and relaxation at a level way beyond what I can ever do consciously. Again, there’s this example where. I’ve just inherited that, that information and in the psychological world, if somebody is shaking or trembling after an accident, if the culture has told me that’s a symptom of shock and anxiety or a panic attack, I’m going to try and stop that and inadvertently shut down the body’s recovery response, which we can talk about more at the, towards the end, because that for me, if we put that down as the fifth faux pas,
Bruce Hildebrand: Can you tell us more Richmond about the authoring of the book that Kelly McGonigal published? The joy of movement titled how exercise helps us find happiness, hope, connection, and courage. Tell us more about Kelly. And. her journey and what inspired you when you first heard her TED talk and what really touched on this topic for you?
Richmond Heath: So I haven’t heard of her book So first thing that’s inspires obviously need to go and get a copy of that and see that so no I haven’t heard anything about that and look again the thing for me that most interested me was More so around the phenomenon of someone being able to acknowledge, wow, I’ve been outputting information, which wasn’t as accurate or as effective as it could be rather than so much around the stress and how we approach that was very much for me in the talk was. Yeah, that sense of being able to acknowledge and having the strength and the courage within ourselves to say, hey, I was doing like this. It wasn’t great. It could be better. In her case, she’s even saying, look, I was doing it wrong. What I was telling you was making you sicker. And I’m not suggesting that with these faux pas in Pilates. I don’t think really any of them are going to make us worse. But they do potentially limit us. So that’s why I brought that topic to the discussion because it can be a hard thing to hear. Have someone say, Hey, guys, we could do this better or maybe you’re not doing it that way. Or so it’s just grounding it in that sense of, you know, it’s okay. We’re all doing our best. We’re all passing on the information that we have inherited and the culture that we work in. But it doesn’t mean that we need to hide behind that and we can have the courage to go, look, ultimately, we’re here to help improve people’s movements, their bodies, their lives, their relationships. So let’s just put ourselves aside and actually step into well, how can we do this even more effectively and better than we’ve been doing today.
Bruce Hildebrand: And if we bring it back to the objective of the Pilates Diaries podcast, Richmond. The sharing of the stories of the impact of Pilates. Pilates, I think can impact your life in so many ways. And I’m very aware that the listeners to the podcast range many years from those who perhaps have been in the early stages of teaching to those keen enthusiasts for it, but also those who’ve taught for a number of years. What I hear you speaking of is coming from a place of maturity where you’ve traversed the years as a long term physiotherapist and seen. Some practices work better than others. Some practices seem to have nil effect and you drop those off pretty quickly, but it’s through the traveling of time that you put more and more information together. I love the deep dive discussions that we have on a regular basis. Offline that allow us to explore what’s been the latest what’s been in your inner circle of new discoveries, new pieces of the puzzle, new conduits that link so many things together. And I think that’s all our responsibilities as movement practitioners and exercise professionals. And the rest that has all that come together. And I could say it in Kelly’s list of books as well. You mentioned about the stress title in a Ted talk accompanies her book called the upside of stress. She’s also published a book on the neuroscience of change and yoga for pain relief, as well as the science of compassion along with that original book I mentioned called the joy of movement. So what an interesting lady. Obviously we’ll definitely be putting the links to her various publications in the show notes for this episode.
Richmond Heath: Yeah, and I think you’re right, Bruce, about these faux pas that we’re going to talk about for me, they’ve all come out of my, cross pollination a lot of them out of, you know, functional and therapeutic breathwork training that I did with an amazing Australian physio who lives in Hawaii at the moment, Campbell Will, also stuff that I learned through, you, when I first started doing Pilates with you that really changed my paradigm around movement and lumbar flexion and stuff, we’ll get to that one and then also work with Um, you know, a workshop I did many years ago with Bonnie Bainbridge Cohen of body mind centering and different perspectives and then, eventually running into Dr. David Berceli and TRE. Very much it’s about trying to integrate knowledge and experiences outside the narrow limitations of stuff that we get taught in order to enhance. the benefits and effects of Pilates, which is, why we’re all here and why we’re listening, because we love Pilates. You know, It’s been an invaluable part of my life when I make sure I get to three, even though they’re pretty basic mat classes, if I get to three of those a week, I wake up the next day going, I’m feeling freer and there’s a progression in my body and my being. And for me, importantly, it’s not just about going on, my body’s better, it’s less painful, but then everything starts to function better. everyone listening to this already knows.
Bruce Hildebrand: And it’s a great practice. That’s the benefits of keeping it up having a mindfulness and a presence to it the whole time, including for the listeners who are simple punters who love Pilates in essence and enjoy going along and may not have that Pilates training under their belt, still so many benefits to it. And probably the key message in amongst that for consumers of Pilates is make sure you keep seeking out teachers that inspire you teachers that are continuing to explore what’s possible with their own understanding of the human body and integration that they can bring to their classes.
Richmond Heath: Yeah, for sure. And, I wouldn’t have got to this information that we’re going to share without, exploring different things. And all of these pas that I’m going to reflect upon have all come out of my own embodied experience. You know, There’s been information that I’ve been given and explored, but it’s about, yeah, taking that and taking that into my Pilates practice.
Bruce Hildebrand: So I’m curious to chat further about Campbell Will, Kelly McGonigal, and Bonnie Bainbridge Cohen, Richmond. Let’s dive into these faux pas that you’ve come up with and pull them apart a little bit and explore the integration of all these different elements of breath trauma and, allowing people to focus on their embryological body.
Richmond Heath: Let me run through them no particular order, and there’s a reason why I want to run through the title of all of them in this order. First of all, when we’re as instructors telling people to always breathe in or out in a certain direction of movement. The second one is when we’re telling people to always breathe out through the mouth and I’m not saying everyone’s doing this, but these are very common in the Pilates culture that certainly my experience of it. The third one is always trying to stabilize the core while moving the periphery. The fourth one is always guiding people to focus on their neuromuscular system. And the fifth one is always telling people to control shaking and tremoring during Pilates. And the reason why I wanted to read those five out in a row is because the common denomination in all of those is the word at the start, always. And so I want to be really clear to everyone, this is not saying in any way that any of those things are wrong or bad. So it’s not like saying, oh, you’re making mistakes, this is really bad. But if we’re always doing all of these things, we’re potentially limiting other experiences and having more effectiveness in Pilates. So again, it’s not wrong. We’re not doing the wrong thing, but there’s more we can do in each of these different areas.
Bruce Hildebrand: And a couple of things there is the curiosity to move outside of the always and avoid being attached to things having to be an absolute certain way. And the other thing, Richmond, is the willingness for the ego to like you mentioned about Kelly, make a confession that in fact she didn’t know it all when she was in her twenties and thirties that through the years a willingness to let go of the ego and having to be right about something Is what allowed her the freedom and expansion to explore move into new fields of study.
Richmond Heath: Yeah, absolutely. in Kelly’s sort of acknowledgement of Kelly. That was even more significant because she had to admit that what I was telling you was wrong and was having a negative impact on your health and well being. So that’s a whole other level. Whereas these ones that I’m talking about, we’re not saying any of these are wrong. It’s only if we’re only always doing these things that we’re missing out on greater opportunities. And all of these that we’re going to cover Bruce. They’ve all come out of my own personal experience. So it’s not just like I’ve read the book and now I’m going to tell you all about it. It’s I’ve done a training or I’ve had an experience or I’ve discovered things or started to think about things in different ways. But ultimately, they’ve all come out of my practice. And, you know, probably for the last year and ever since doing the. Functional and Therapeutic Breathwork Training with Campbell Will year and a half, two years ago. Just about every time I go to my Pilates class, I’m in there, I’m halfway through a thing, and they’re telling me to do this breath and this movement, and I just want to go, Oh my God, and I just don’t follow their instructions all the time, and I just chop and change, and I explore. So, Just about every class I go to, I’m like, Oh my God, I have to tell people this, we have to be sharing this. There’s, and again, To be really clear, there’s going to be a lot of Pilates instructors out there who aren’t always doing all these things and you’ve got great levels of training and experience and knowledge and skills and mixing it up. So if that’s you, then all kudos to you and you can listen to it and that will just reinforce what you’re doing. But. Certainly my experience of the Pilates culture in general, in the Australian context, a lot of these things are set in stone. This is what I did in my early training. This is what, I did my mat work class and this is what they told me to do. And I just roll it out and I roll it out and it has a benefit. Don’t get me wrong. We all know that, but in my experience, personally in my own body and then also in my work with other people there’s often a lot more available.
Bruce Hildebrand: Excellent. So only ever breathing or always breathing in a certain direction of movement. Richmond, can you expand on that for us?
Richmond Heath: Yep. And this is very, very, simple one. So let’s just think about lateral flexion. Say someone’s standing up and they’re going to flex to the side. So often people be told a certain thing. So, Okay, as you reach down, you’re going to breathe out. Okay. And then as you breathe in, you’re going to come back up and breathe out and we keep doing it that way. So if we start to think about, all right why would we be doing that? And what are we trying to achieve? Or the other example might be, if someone’s lying on the floor doing a roll up, okay, we want you to breathe out as you roll up so that, your abdominals are sinking in and there’s all this focus about your abdominals, abdominals, We’ll get to that in faux pas number four. But Again, if we think about it with lateral flexion, it’s such a great example because if you’re flexing to the right, your right side of your ribcage is contracting and squeezing down. So really great for your right side of your ribcage to breathe out and contract and go further into that. But what about the left side of the ribcage? Ah, so we’re wanting that to expand. So if I only ever breathe out as I’m going down to the right I’m actually limiting the left side of the ribcage’s ability to open and then vice versa back the other way. That’s a common example. Same thing with a roll up from the floor. So legs out straight, gonna roll up all the way up into sitting. So if I’m focusing on just saying, Hey, I just want segmental movement and I want to deepen my abdominals and my transverse abdominis and all that sort of stuff. Yeah, it might be doing a Deep, slow exhale in the curl up is going to be great, but what about the posterior ribs? What about all the muscles that can help us roll up from the posterior of the body? If I’m trying to contract the ribs and shut them down, why wouldn’t I be inflating my lungs, creating like, little blow up balloons at the back there that are going to help contribute to the forwards movement? Now again, what it means is that I’m not saying, okay, therefore you should be doing it the other way around. I’m saying no, no, no, do it always. Why not sometimes roll up and hold your breath. Why not do some sniffing breaths as you come up. So challenging everything. And so the practice that I tend to do in my Pilates classes, don’t tell my instructors this, although they know I tend to do a bit of my own thing, is rather than following that sort of singular rhythm. Okay, as you roll up, breathe out. Now, as you roll back, even if, whether it’s, you know, take a breath and then breathe out as you roll back. All I will tend to do, Bruce, is I’ll just add an extra, Part of the breath cycle in. So, example, just rolling up, I’ll go, I’ll breathe out as I roll up. Good. I might breathe out as I roll down and then I’ll take another breath. I’ll breathe in. Oh, so I can’t remember what I did. Out and then in. Then I’ll do an out breath without moving. So, The next time in my breathing cycle, as I’m rolling up, now I’m breathing in. And then as I roll out, I breathe out. Then I take another breath and you can add that sort of stationary breath in at any point of the movement. So there could be value in doing it when you’re lying back down because it might be easier and, or you could be doing it when you’re at the height of the muscular contraction. So a lot of the breathing that I’m aware of has come from this focus of, oh, we’re trying to deepen the abdominals. And again, that’s great. Use the out breath to deepen the abdominals and do all that stuff. But don’t limit it to that, because then we’re limiting the ability of the body to, you know, curl up through the posterior ribs, if you’re doing that, and the reality that the whole human organism, when it’s really free and pulsating and alive and vital, and it has its motility, breathing’s not something that just happens in the ribcage and the diaphragm. The whole human organism slightly expands, so why would I always want to be trying to contract it and shrink it down, when the natural impulse in the body is to expand And again, don’t get stuck on going off. So I’m always going to use a three breath cycle. So in one movement, out another, take whatever breath, mix it up, play with it. And it really came out of when I was doing the training with Campbell Will. Which I highly recommend if anyone’s interested in breathwork. I think it’s one of the most fantastic, he’s one of the most knowledgeable guys I know. And he really works through the full spectrum from just mindfulness of breath through to super ventilation. But what I love about his training is he’s like, look, you can do a 20 minute or a 30 minute breathwork practice every day. You might do 350 breaths in that time. What about the other 24, 000 breaths you’re going to take through the day? I think they’re more important than your breathwork practice as a stand alone. Do them both. But he made this fantastic quote one day when we’re talking about stuff. And he said, and I think he was quoting someone else, if you don’t own your diaphragm in any given position, then you don’t own that position. That position owns you. And that was a profound moment for me because what I started to explore when I was working with my breathing in Pilates was how often my diaphragm, which is meant to be free and flexible to breathe, vitality in life, was being used for stabilizing or using my obliques to stabilize so my ribs couldn’t actually move. And you know, that real rigidity and locking down. So for me, this was very much about wanting to mix it up so that the diaphragm could be free and as much as possible, be free to move in and out without needing to take on the role of stabilization.
Bruce Hildebrand: What a fantastic overview. I’m busting to meet Campbell. I haven’t, touched base with him yet. So again, we’ll be dropping his details in the show notes for those interested. Thanks for the recommendation as always Richmond. So, I love your play on words a few moments ago, Richmond, about not always doing something, but doing something in all ways. All possible ways, all movement directions, all types of expansion into your ribcage, in all phases of the movement. One thing that I’m constantly mindful of, particularly in the context of the instructor training programs that we deliver, that I’m involved in delivering, is what is the mindset of a beginner teacher? So, And I just want to highlight that for a moment because it’s a classic case of you speaking with so many years of experience, easy to have the oversight of How much information you’re integrating from your physiotherapy basis, from your advanced training with Campbell all of your TRE related things, all of your Pilates training, all of your Bowen therapy, all these things coming together. So keeping things simple and some guidelines to run with, probably the key thing for me that jumps out is trusting the embodied experience of it and keeping up the practice for yourself. Like you say, along the lines of upwards of 20, 000 breaths a day, is it just the one or two? hours or minutes that you’re focusing on that consciously. How does that flood into your day to day activities? My dialogue that I love to share with clients on a daily basis is they come to class for the cordial, but they need it to dilute into the rest of their week. Otherwise, what’s the point if it doesn’t have some practical carry over? So I’m loving what you’re saying along the lines of keeping a presence of mind, keeping a mindfulness about every position that you move through on a daily basis. And granted this does take a high level of mindfulness and practice is what’s your diaphragm up to? When are you feeling yourself hyperventilating, stressing too much? What’s your diaphragm up to in that moment in time? Um, I I think it can have a huge bearing on what our. Mindset is up to you as well.
Richmond Heath: And to make it a really simple, practical takeaway for any Pilates teacher, whether you’re at the very start of the career, end of the career, all you really need to know is if you’re always teaching people to breathe in or out in a certain direction, just mix it up, reverse it. And I would encourage you to start playing with this in your own life and your own Pilates experience because you’ll start to experience it and then it’ll make more sense. You don’t have to learn it. So, If you find yourself always going, yeah, breathe out when you do this way, breathe in, then first of all, reverse it. That’s the simplest instruction that we have. And especially if you’re starting out in your career, don’t waste, 20 years until you do all the other expanded knowledge and stuff to integrate it. Just start incorporating that into your personal practice first. And then once you have an understanding of the value of that, then you can introduce that to your clients. And the easiest way to do that, as I say, is to keep it. If you’re really working with breathing cycles during your Pilates and sometimes do and sometimes don’t, would be my recommendation. Sometimes forget about it entirely is just adding in that pause. and adding in the breath. So if you’re breathing out this movement, you’re breathing in, then hold the position, don’t move, take the next part of the cycle and that will automatically start to change the breathing over. So doing the movement directions in different breath, inhale, exhale patterns. All right. so the second one. Always breathing out through the mouth. Now Again, this was something that I never understood, and I hear this all the time. I hear this regularly, people like, breathe all the way out, breathe through, squeeze out all that garbage, all that carbon dioxide, all that terrible waste product that we’ve got to get out of the body. Now, if that’s my understanding of carbon dioxide, then of course I’m going to try and breathe it out and that’s going to make sense. What I didn’t know until I did the breathwork training is that carbon dioxide is not really just a waste product and in fact the higher levels of carbon dioxide we can tolerate in our system, the better our oxygenation occurs at the level of our tissues. So let me just explain this a little bit. So when we think about oxygenation, we often talk about blood saturation. So, you know, You put the little pulse oximeter and it says, Oh, you’ve got 98 percent blood oxygen oxidation. That’s great. Now, if you play with breath holds and all that stuff, you’ll generally find that you can hold your breath till you’re just about going to wet your pants. And generally your blood oxygenation levels hardly going to change at all. Your blood sets aren’t really going to go down. And they might, with practice and skills, you might start getting them down. However, at the tissue level, carbon dioxide and the level of carbon dioxide and the amount of carbon dioxide which is in the blood and in the tissues determines how much of the oxygen that gets bonded onto the red blood cells is able to leave the blood And go into the tissues. So Campbell explained it this way. I thought this was a beautiful analogy. He said, you know, you’ve seen American films where a taxi pulls up to a, house or it’s generally like an apartment block and there’s a guy there standing there who opens the door. So Campbell explains it this way. It’s like you breathe in. oxygen comes in, comes into the blood system, it gets onto a red blood cells like a taxi, so it jumps into the taxi, it locks onto the taxi drives it around, takes it down to wherever else in, you know, New York or in your physical body. However, in this analogy, that backseat of the taxi doesn’t have a handle on the inside of the door. The oxygen can’t get off the red blood cell without carbon dioxide there to open the door. So carbon dioxide is like the little guy standing at the door opening the taxi door. The more carbon dioxide you have in the system, the more oxygen is actually able to get out of the blood and get into the tissues where it’s needed. So this is where when we look at, high performance breath training, there’s a lot of stuff where you’re going right, we’re going to start training our breath and we’re going to hold our breath while we’re exercising. We’re only going to breathe through the nose. We’re going to limit the amount of carbon dioxide that we are blowing off. to increase our capacity to tolerate higher and higher levels of carbon dioxide because paradoxically what makes us have the urge to breathe when we feel like we’ve got air hunger and we’re running out of breath is not actually dropping oxygen. it’s actually increasing carbon dioxide. And so people who have experience of what they would call panic attacks, we’ll cover this in faux pas 5, when the body’s starting to shake and tremble and they’re getting anxious, the research shows that there will be changes in their carbon dioxide levels around an hour before they start to have that panic experience. And so what’s critical to the optimization of the oxygenation of the tissues is how much carbon dioxide we’re retaining. And the main reason why we take big breaths and we start hyperventilating when we’re exercising is to get rid of carbon dioxide. The whole point of a panic attack is not because I’m going, I can’t breathe. I need to suck in more oxygen. It’s going, Oh my God, there’s too much carbon dioxide. I’ve got to get rid of it. And so it’s partly about blowing it down. So, If we’re always encouraging people to take huge breaths and to breathe all the way out, now that’s fantastic in terms of creating, in a range contraction and mobilizing the ribcage. It’s not wrong or bad when you’re wanting to work on that. But if the standard practice is, oh, you’re, and I hear this a lot, you do your Pilates breathing in through your nose, out through your mouth, when you’re breathing out through your mouth, you’re blowing off carbon dioxide and actually inadvertently limiting the amount of oxygenation that can happen in the tissues, which is, of course, is going to increase pain, tension, bracing um, Holding and all those things that we’re trying to reverse. So the simple takeaway here is, again, start in your own personal practice. Start with only breathing through your nose, reducing how much you’re breathing, maybe even play with breath holds, and explore this as a concept. There’s a great book, highly recommend, which is called The O2 Advantage. Highly recommend that. It’s got all this sort of stuff explained. Most of us just think, oh, I’ve got to breathe more, but most of us are chronically over breathing. And the same thing happens when we’re over breathing or we’re over expiring during Pilates. We’re reducing the capacity for those tissues to oxygenate and adapt and stretch and move more freely.
Bruce Hildebrand: So fascinating. The level of balance we need to find with the oxygen and the carbon dioxide, largely unconscious in the way it is processed and balanced in our normal physiology. I’ve heard breathing is one of the main conscious tools that we have to regulate our nervous system. by consciously choosing to breathe certain ways and to have a greater understanding of that and to be able to influence that in different ways, particularly in the context of exercise like you’re talking about. So helpful, so, so helpful for more and more practitioners to do the deep dive. My most recent reading around breath work was on the book Breath by James Nesta, which I recommend to a range of different people on a weekly basis. You’ve had a chance to dive into that one as well.
Richmond Heath: Yeah, absolutely. Love that one as well. The and I love them both. So if you’re interested in this topic and if you’re teaching people movement and exercise, you should be interested in this topic. It’s absolutely central. I would say read them both. The thing I do like about the Oxygen Advantage book specific to Pilates instructors is it’s much more focused on sport. And on the integration and practical experiences for you to practice and then to be able to potentially pass on to your clients in the movement and exercise based setting. Whereas my recollection is, you know, James Nesta talks about that a little bit, but the oxygen advantage, has programs and exercises that you can follow at a basic level. So the. Patrick McKeown or McKeown, I don’t know how to pronounce it. He’s an Irish guy. he’s the author of the Oxygen Advantage. He’s been doing this work for years. And I also recommend, he’s got a great podcast. So that’s somewhere else where you can go and start to dive into this whole field. It’s called the same thing, the Oxygen Advantage podcast.
Bruce Hildebrand: We’ve got a great list of show note links for everyone listening to this episode. So check those out for yourself.
Richmond Heath: And now you know why we’re so old, Bruce, because it takes that long to read all these books and learn all this information, so hopefully and certainly for me, it’s taken just a whole lot of exploration and personal experience, so hopefully through sharing these resources and this information, people don’t have to spend 20 years, breathing a certain way or moving a certain way to discover that on their own by reading 400 books that, through this sharing and lots of other resources that people can move through those processes more quickly to get more effect and more efficiency and more benefits from their Pilates sooner in their life and their practice and for their clients than it took me.
Bruce Hildebrand: Another guest on the Pilates Diaries podcast was wonderful colleague Jakki Tobin. She has done loads of work with Tess Graham, who is the creator of BreatheAbility. And that big takeaway from reading that book a number of years ago for myself was the over breathing that we largely do as a population. And how little the image that stood out for me in reading that book was considering the size of the volume that we breathe, imagining that was a size of a cloud and to gradually reduce the volume of that cloud over time, a number of days, a number of weeks, a number of months see how little we need to actually get by on and how we can manage not in a restricting type of way, but just curiosity around exploring how much was I perhaps over breathing unnecessarily.
Richmond Heath: And that’s been a profound experience for me. Again, this isn’t just theory that I’m saying, I’ve read this book and want to tell you is in my own personal practice of Pilates, I am amazed the things that I’m doing now, not that I’m amazingly high level or anything, but the capacity that I have and I’m doing these exercises and these movements. And I’m breathing really freely and easily through my nose and it’s super relaxed in comparison to, a long time ago. And one of the things I discovered, Bruce, is when I used to bend forwards, to tie my shoelaces up, I generally couldn’t breathe. That’s what I discovered. And it wasn’t just that my guts were a bit fat or whatever. There was these patterns around. And often there’s a lot of unconscious tension and trauma patterns. That’s not just biomechanical. Whereas these days I can lean forwards, tie my shoes up and I’m like, I can still breathe. Now there’s obviously more mobility in my rib cage and all sorts of different stuff. But yeah, for me, I’ve found it profound that my Pilates experience now is so much more relaxing. I generally are getting much deeper into sort of micro flow states and getting insights and that will come out at the end of the system. My mind as well as my body is calmed down and I’m just able to move or stretch in ways that I never thought I’d be able to simply by maintaining this. Again, not all the time, but most of the time effectively under breathing, you know, reducing my breathing, not trying to restrict it, but just relaxing and letting it. And then my diaphragm frees up and more of my body starts to open up and move.
Bruce Hildebrand: Interesting juxtaposition and contrary thinking it takes time, I think, to to integrate this with what we do as our regular practice, have an awareness and a mindfulness around it, and then put it into practice in your Pilates day to day activities, of course.
Richmond Heath: That’s right. And so that’s faux pas number two is we’ve all been told, I get the carbon dioxide out. That’s bad. That’s a waste product. You’ve got to get it out, get as much out as you can. And all we need to know is that’s not actually true. And over breathing is. having a limiting effect. So let’s start playing with under breathing as well. Again, don’t throw out over breathing, don’t throw out end of range expiration and all that stuff. You still want to do it, but don’t make that a set in stone belief that we then follow through on everything we do.
Bruce Hildebrand: The Canadian physiotherapist who I read about many years ago, who was the first guy I’d come across who was very much downplaying the impact of Pilates because it’s Inability to be as functionally effective as it needs to be. And he used the example of being able to deal with 120 kilograms running at 40 Ks an hour straight at you on a footy pitch. He had a great point. I think Stuart McGill was his name. And. To be gentle and soft and free to move in your body won’t have you functionally be able to deal with that. So intra abdominal pressure concepts locking into the stability model. that allows you to lift Olympic style, weight belt type of shifting that iron. I think it’s a real spectrum of functions that our body has the ability to adapt to that we’re talking through and, and, and, and, to consider that it’s all of those things is really dependent on your functional outcome and reasons for participating in various training.
Richmond Heath: Yeah. And I would just throw in a little caution there around Stuart McGill is I’m pretty confident that he’s never done Aikido or any energy based martial art. So he probably doesn’t have much experience biomechanical model not, dissing him. But again, this is one of the things where our limited knowledge base can actually really significantly impact what we think is possible. So if I’ve got that model, I’ve got a brace and I’ve got a hold and that’s how you make that object. If you’ve seen some extraordinary martial arts, energetic people who can move energy and stuff outside their bodies and stop clocks and make, hankies get hard and smash chopsticks with hankies, then there’s a whole other field there. I’m not discounting that, but this is another example where the information we inherit. from teachers can often be really helpful, but it can also be very self limiting as well.
Bruce Hildebrand: Can you speak from your experience of and this is you giving your opinion fundamentally when you have, looked into the work of Stuart McGill and my experience has been that it’s been limiting for X, Y, and Z reasons. So I’m
Richmond Heath: aware of the work of Stuart McGill, and in my opinion I have a little bit of caution around taking that model. Now, on one hand, I completely agree that when we’re trying to maximize our output, as you say, whether it’s weightlifting or meeting a, running back on the field, that we’re going to, use and mobilize all of our resources in order to meet that. So, Yeah, no, we’re probably going to be involving the diaphragm or bracing for impact and all that sort of stuff. But at the same time, my caution is that that model and understanding can be also limiting based on the idea that the weight is only ever being met by the neuromuscular system. And by that, what I mean is if anyone’s had any experience with martial arts or eastern masters who have the capacity to, move energy or redirect energy in any way, including outside their own body. Or if someone’s got a background with Aikido, an Aikido master would be very unlikely to say, well, when that 140 kilos is coming towards you, the answer is you need to brace and get hard. That’s very much a Western neuroscientific model, there may be other ways of approaching that. So again, this is where what we inherit often is coming from the limitations of the worldview. And my personal experience of this, Bruce, think we spoke about this in the original Pilates Diaries interview we did, was when I was doing a Vipassana course. So I went to a 10 day silent meditation where just Constantly meditating into your body. Now, I’ve got all my physio background knowledge about strength. How long does it take to improve your strength from, 30 kilos? It’s going to take weeks and months and years and the filaments have got to grow and blah, blah, blah. What I experienced in that moment was as my mind started to get out of the way, my body started to move spontaneously and my strength started to increase in an almost exponential way, which made no sense whatsoever within my understanding of the strength model that I’d inherited through physiotherapy. So I went from the start of the course, not being able to lift my arms above the shoulders because I’d had chronic Shoulder impingement and tension to after a few days of laying spontaneous movement at one point my body. would be moving itself and I just let it stretch and move and roll around because it just felt extraordinary. So it was like that shaking and trembling where you get through Pilates, but just amplified and where at one point I remember my feet being up against the wall and I was on one arm. and I could do a push up. I could push my whole body weight up and down with one arm. And I’m distinctly remembering at the time just going, okay everything I was taught about strength at uni has just gone out the window. I can’t explain what’s happening here. I didn’t have the models or whatever, but what I knew was that biomechanical model of the muscles are doing this and that there was something else going on. And we might talk about that at another time, because my summary about that is that strength is a memory.
Bruce Hildebrand: So just so I’m clear on that, you’re inverted in a handstand with your feet balanced against the wall on one hand and able to do a single hand push up overhead?
Richmond Heath: With absolute ease. again, if I hadn’t have experienced myself, I’d go, wow, what a fascinating story, but I was there, I experienced it. And so again, I’m not saying how do I have ways of making sense of that, but what I’m saying is in that moment, it shattered everything that I was already preexisting about. This is how strength is that I’d been taught at uni and spent all this money and time learning. I’m not, discounting that that can work, but because we’ve got a model of that. It was also can be limiting our experience and preventing those other experiences. So that’s all I was saying in relation to, Stuart McGill’s information about the bracing and the need to, my recollection again, a long time ago, he might have moved on, but there’s a whole lot of stuff around about immobilizing the spine in order to function in your daily life. And to me, I’d say that’s a coping strategy. That’s not healing. And there’s a difference. And so this leads us on to faux pas number three, which is a faux pas that I’d been teaching in the clinical pilates. Sphere because of the physiotherapy model of clinical Pilates at the time. And, all the research that was happening, which I actually undid and learned, and it was life transforming experience, both in my own healing and progression of my own low back issues, as well as handing on to my clients. And the classic example for me was, I think it was Hodges, who did all this research. About TA and stabilization and that was the whole thing and for 20 years, everyone was teaching TA stuff, transverse abdominus and blah, and then eventually after 15 years, they turn around and said, Oh, hang on, sorry nah, that’s we’ve something else. I also distinctly remember. Sitting in the kitchen of the physiotherapy clinic where I was teaching Pilates and there was this big article up on the wall that one of the owners had put up on the wall and it had all been highlighted and it said, oh, the latest research shows that non steroidal anti inflammatories are actually increasing inflammation, blah, blah, blah, really bad, don’t use them. And the thing for me in that moment is going, oh great, so today we’re telling everyone not to use them, but for the last two years we’ve been going, the evidence base is showing us that we should be using them, without the awareness of saying, what’s the evidence base going to say in 500 years time? it’s going to look back and laugh its heads off at the stuff that we’re saying at the moment. Again, this is very much coming from that physio model where it’s like, well, we’ve got all the research, we know what we’re doing, clinical Pilates is better because we’re physios rather than Pilates instructors, which is in my opinion completely the wrong way around. But again, it’s just this sense that we inherit information, frameworks and models from our teachers where often those teachers don’t necessarily have an understanding that there’s much more available than what I know today. And so they’re often taught as truths and this is what the research says without the humility to say, take them all with a grain of salt. Don’t get too rigid and fixed in these because there’s probably going to be more we understand in the next decade or the next century that we’re not understanding at the moment.
Bruce Hildebrand: We’re all on a journey is what I’m hearing, Richmond. And the difference between laws and rules and guidelines and specifications, they’re all a moving target. And it’s important, I think, that we keep tapping into and trusting our own intuition and our own felt sense as we move through this journey of exercise and the exploration of Pilates. Let’s take a little breath there. I’ve got a story I’d love to tell you, and then we’ll be straight back into it. I often think about the day my studios got lighter. October 2017, two studios, a team of teachers, and a timetable with gaps in it I was paying rent on either way. So instead of micromanaging every hour myself, I handed the gaps to the teachers already working for me. They hired the room back off me by the hour and ran their own clients in it. And what a change. About 80% of my workload disappeared almost overnight. The teachers ran their own show. The clients saw nothing different, a timetable with their favourite teachers on it. That experiment is what’s now Trimio, which to be clear, is my own startup, so my bias is out in the open. Today, the app does what I did by hand. A studio lists the hours it isn’t using, a teacher hires them and runs their own session, and a client finds their favourite teacher closer to home. Have a look at trimio.app if you’re curious. Right, let’s get back to Richmond. Tell us more about your faux pas number three, always stabilizing the core while moving the periphery. You had an experience of that yourself achieving some new mobility in your lumbar spine.
Richmond Heath: Absolutely, straight out of my own experience and my learning of Pilates um, you know, as a student of yours, Bruce. So again, in my physio course and that model around stabilizing, there was this whole focus on, okay, you’ve got to stabilize the lumbar spine because, oh, if you bend too much, the disc is going to bulge or whatever. So there’s all this information. And again, this for me was part of that information around Stuart McGill about teaching people how to brace their low back. I think it’s a useful like I said, of crutches in order to function in daily life, but you can’t stop there. And so in the, physio culture that I inherited, there was a lot of stuff about stabilizing the core. So, Okay, keep your lower back stable as you move your legs. Don’t, you know, if you’re on four point kneeling, do leg hip extension, but don’t let your lumbar spine bend. extent. Now again, none of this is wrong or bad. These are skills. These are things that you should be able to do. Or if you’re, doing a chariot pull or something on the reformer, it’s like keep your stable shoulder blades back and down and pull your arms back and down and don’t let them move. Now again, great skill, but generally what ends up happening is we just train people into rigidity and immobility that has an impact on their capacity to move. So as someone who had experienced chronic back pain for many, many years, to the point of, there were two big times in my life where it got really bad and I had sciatic pain and numbness and stuff. I couldn’t sleep overnight and there were two times where I couldn’t go up and down stairs because my left leg was so weak. So this is coming from someone who had massive chronic back pain. Now, the model I inherited was that was a disc bulge. So whatever you do, do all your McKenzie extensions, try and push that disc back in. Whatever you do, don’t bend forwards because you’re going to bulge the disc out. That’s going to be the rest of your life. But also learn how to stabilise your back so you can bend forwards and keep your back lumbar spine stiff and rigid. Again, may be useful in the acute setting, but I’ll never forget doing kitten stretches, you know, like little cats and you’re getting me to start to do lumbar flexion. Buying four point kneeling and tilting my pelvis and saying something really simple like, oh, you know, we want to get your lumbar flexion back And having that response of, hang on, flexion is really bad for me, we’ve got to stabilize, we’ve got to, and so there’s often in Pilates, an over focus on stabilizing the core or stabilizing the spine or not letting the core move. while we’re moving the periphery. Now, again, that is a fantastic exercise if you want to start to lengthen your hip flexors or get your psoas to start working rather than all the movement coming in your lumbar spine. But if we always stabilize the core and move the periphery, guess what happens? We’re just going to train rigidity and flexibility. and immobility and we’re not actually training people in dynamic core stability and training the body to have the capacity to stabilize itself through range rather than this concept of I got to maintain neutral spine all the time. So at other times I’d say to people stabilize your periphery and move your core, which is what you’re doing like a kitten or a cat stretch, and do both of those things. So once again, do not get stuck always going, oh, I must stabilize this part of my body. I must not let that move so that I’m getting the range and the movement in this other part of my body, often in a different segment or the periphery. Again, not wrong or bad, do that, but also then integrate, okay, now we’re going to do the same movement. We’re going to let the movement come from the entire body. We’re going to let your left ankle help with your right shoulder so that we’re actually reintegrating the whole entire body’s capacity to move and to be responsive. And the classic example for me is that when you’ve got a body that is connected and integrated and you’re running along and you start to roll your ankle, what actually happens is your knee lets go, your hip lets go and you fall over. And your entire body responds to that extreme range in your ankle. Unless, of course, you’ve been told, oh, you’ve got to strengthen up only your ankle, you’ve got to keep running, you do that, and the rest of the body doesn’t actually respond to that. It’s normal and healthy to fall over if your ankle twists to the point where it’s going to damage your, lateral ligaments. It’s not healthy. And it’s disconnected to be able to go, I’m going to keep running. Oh, my God. I’ve just ripped. I’ve got six weeks out of sport because it’s showing this deeper pattern where there’s a disconnection. Now, I’ve gone into a whole other train there. So let me just come back a little bit. That’s again, that’s about integrating the movement. So we’re not just focusing on the segment or the part. Stabilize this one and move that one. Great, beautiful. At other times we need to let the body move in relationship and integrated different parts of the body. So we’re doing the movement and all of the body is moved so we can come at it again with all these different options and that creates more variability, more flexibility, more possibilities in the system. And that’s what a healthy, more reorganized neuromuscular system looks like.
Bruce Hildebrand: This is a whole body of work that you’re talking about Richmond giving some freedom to the form of what I initially trained in Pilates. This is the repertoire. These are the exercises. These are the planes of movement. Stick to those. And then coming across movement modalities such as Gerudo and gyrotonic and even more contemporary dance rather than classical ballet, where the form is the artistry versus the freedom and the exploration is the expression.
Richmond Heath: Yeah. And, not dissing Joseph Pilates, he was a man. He was German, so there’s no surprises that everything’s going to be very rigid and linear and fixed in this way, in a sense, for me, is like very left brain, very logical, very rational, very fantastic. There’s a whole culture of Pilates spread all around the world. Brilliant. But what we’re talking about here in terms of that integration movement is a little bit more of the feminine sort of movement, the right brain the integration of all parts of the body and the form and the quality, not just in, linear planes and, and always in a rigid controlled fashion.
Bruce Hildebrand: The difficulty, I think, as we do a sidestep into the commercialization of Pilates, to control things, allow someone to scale things via a franchise or that sort of model, to run a training where it only has to be done this way, limiting things can really put a real restriction and a harness really on where you can go exploring with your Pilates?
Richmond Heath: Yeah. Or corset. creates a certain form. And for me, Bruce, again, it’s not necessarily saying, Oh, okay, don’t do Pilates. Don’t have, set structures. Don’t just do whatever you want. And so for me, the simple guide to faux pas number four is in training to incorporate the principles. Yeah, absolutely. Stabilize the core, move the periphery. Great. That’s one end of the spectrum. Now, let’s do the opposite. Stabilize the periphery, move the core. Great, stage two. Stage three, let’s do movement that’s moving, allowing the core and the periphery to move in relationship with each other. Again, it’s not about saying, oh, we have to go from one end of the beam to controlling and rigid. I’m saying that’s three simple little understandings which are built, if they’re built into basic Pilates training. All of a sudden opens up a whole spectrum. Same with faux pas one. It’s not saying, Oh, you’ve got to do 50 years of breathwork training. It’s like, okay. When you’re teaching people to breathe out on this range of movement, then reverse it, teach them how to breathe in, and then change it. So it’s a simple piece of information that can then have a massive massive through effect, rather than going, you’ve got to go and do 40 years of breathwork training to understand this. These are really simple things that when we step past the faux pas and we go, hey, we can just integrate this little bit of practice, then that can still filter through.
Bruce Hildebrand: So tell us more about faux pas number four that you’ve listed. Always guiding people to focus on their muscular system. Bonnie Bainbridge Cohen’s influence with the body mind centering.
Richmond Heath: So let me start with my most recent experience over the last couple of weeks and months in my personal practice. So I’m someone who, in the trauma model, we kind of have, two primary different states of that the trauma response or the people who are really disconnected from their body or really disconnected from parts of our body. But what we don’t often realize is then when we’re in the sympathetic state, we’re often over connected or over focused or hyper vigilant. in the body. And that’s very much my experience where, you know, you might remember spending years trying to get a bit of hamstring length. And as soon as I move into any kind of stress, they’re so tight. There’s so much neutral pain and tension there. they’re hardly going to let go. And my most recent experience is really focusing in on things other than my neuromuscular system has had a profound change in what I’m experiencing. So what I’ve been doing lately. Is I’ve just been thinking about my bones. And instead of thinking about what muscles I’m moving, or trying to activate, or trying to release, most of the time at the moment, again this is not the only thing to do, this is just giving an example, is I just keep picturing my skeleton. And I’m just a skeleton, and I’m just moving my skeleton. And what I find is that by focusing on my bones, and taking my focus away from all the tension and pain and holding and bracing in my neuromuscular system, my whole system’s a little bit less reactive, and then all of a sudden I can move more freely. And the biggest one for me that’s really happening at the moment is my rib cage. I’d often do roll ups or I’d be doing movements and really focused on the spine and moving, not just moving from the spine, but just moving the bones, deeply connecting into the bones. And so lately what I’ve been really exploring with this going, hang on, instead of thinking about rolling up through my spine and getting to that point where I’m halfway through the roll up and I’m like, I don’t know if I’m going to be able to make it up if I’m a bit stiff, starting to go, hang on. I’ve got all these ribs out here that can help with this movement, and I’m just going to move my ribs. So, What I’ve experienced by just purely now focusing, going, I’m forgetting about my muscular system. I’m not saying everyone needs to do this, but by taking my focus away from all the tension and holding and pain there. I’m getting heaps more range, I’m getting heaps easier quality, heaps better quality of movement. And again, this is linked in with the model I inherited as a physiotherapist. These are the muscles that are doing the movement, so we want to focus on the muscles. And it’s got to make this muscle longer or shorter and that no one’s ever said to me, Hey, just forget about your muscles, move your bones, feel your bones, move your bones. And then the experience that I had with Bonnie Bain Bridge Cohen at Body Mind Centering, Workshop many, many years ago, she started talking about, okay, we’re going to move from the fluid in our body. We’re going to move from the water element and she’d go back to embryological stages to make sense. And again, so we have this completely different experience. Of, softness and movement when we connect in and focus on the movement that on the water or the liquid element in the body. Same thing, you can do that with the, with air. So again, it’s about this sense as if we’re always just educating people about the muscle system and pay attention to this and try and relax that muscle and try and do that. One of the limitations that we have in that sense is that we’re limited in how much we can cognitively relax. It’s part of the kind of trauma understanding in the trauma model because if we could cognitively relax everything we would just tell people let go and they’d be enlightened. So sometimes we need to shift our attention. And another example of this, Bruce, again, it’s not about saying only do Pilates and think about your bones. I’m saying don’t get limited, only focusing on and talking to your clients about their muscular system. You might not even think about the fascial system, which is pre organizing movement, but another experience to give you an example of this, where for me, I’ve generally have inherited this model that embodiment is the most important thing. You’ve got to pay attention to your body. And if you’re not, that’s wrong or bad. Whereas another one of my experiences, I’ve been doing a movement practice in the morning where I’ll have my fire lit, I’ll stand in front of the fire with my back to the fire, and there is a shadow cast up onto the wall and the roof. In front of me, because I’m facing away from the fire, and first of all, found it quite an amazing experience because it makes me think about, ancient people in caves and the things on the cave. So, What I will often do is a side to side rhythmical movement sort of experience. And what I also discover is that when I pay attention to my body and I feel all that tension and I’m trying to move my shoulders or loosen up my shoulders. It’s useful, don’t get me wrong. But when I deliberately take my awareness away from my physical body and I really focus on the shadow and I try and like just put all my focus on the shadow as if that’s who and where I am and that’s what I’m moving, guess what happens? My range of movement massively frees up. Things start to change and shift and I can move for, you know, 10 minutes longer than I normally would. Because for me at least, that focusing in on my body is actually all the time has been creating a limitation. So the simple summary here is don’t get caught only talking and focusing on the muscular system. Talk about getting people to connect to their bones and not even to think about using their muscles to move their bones, just be in the bones and move from the bones, move the bones and move from them. Or do things to take the awareness away from the body might give it more freedom. And then at the other end of the spectrum, there might be people who are not very embodied, who you really want to connect into the neuromuscular system. So it’s again about exploring and playing with all these different options rather than only talking it from a Western neuroscientific biomechanical It’s just the muscles. We’ve just got to keep moving the muscles.
Bruce Hildebrand: So many layers to that. I think the somatic layering of the practice of human movement is a huge influence on what you’re up to, and it’s certainly been a big journey of mine over the years as well, Richmond, so. again, that alignment, the alignment that we share with that is pretty profound. And thanks for sharing your passion for it.
Richmond Heath: You’re very welcome. And it reminds me, just when I’m thinking about it now, in Western culture and Western science, the idea of trance is something that’s completely seen as, weird savages, whatever, you know, People banging drums, all that sort of stuff. So, The idea of trance is not something that’s really integrated. and the use of psychedelics, which is starting to be explored in terms of post traumatic stress and chronic pain and all that sort of stuff. And what a lot of those things do, is they actually help us take our ego or our conscious mind away from our body. And lots of us have experience of this, where, you know, you go in the old days, when I was growing up, you go to the nightclub, you’re starting to dance, you’re a little bit self conscious, you’re not dancing you have a few drinks, you loosen up that sense of, personal ego and inhibition, and then all of a sudden you can dance more freely. So what I’m reflecting to here is that sometimes loosening our connection and focus on our body gives it the capacity to move more freely than if we’re always paying attention to it. And that’s what a lot of traditional cultures have done, whether they’re using substances or they’re using rhythmical movement or chanting in order to get out of the way And allow the body to move and express itself. So if all the time the focus is on pay attention to your body, keep being mindful for the body, that’s going to have a benefit. But if you’re always doing that, there’s more available that you and your clients are potentially missing out on.
Bruce Hildebrand: A lot of speak around the science that backs up each of these concepts on longevity that I’ve. been pointed to recently with various programs that clients have recommended. A lot of non science around these concepts that come up through cultures as well, enrichment things like storytelling and chanting and dance and music many layers of that, which who knows the mental wellbeing benefits of that could be well documented across many multiples of theses, I reckon,
Richmond Heath: I totally agree, and as I love to just say to people, what is the evidence base in the science going to tell us in the year 3024? So it’s not saying that what we know is not useful and valuable, but if we look back a thousand years, oh, the dark ages, those people had no idea, but we know what’s going on because we’ve got the research to prove it, rather than going, do you think there might be a reason why, people have done this for 40, in their culture. So again, it’s having that humility and not getting over attached, not to discount what we do know, but keeping that humility and the openness that there’s more available. Again, this links back to the faux pas that we’ve all inherited and just. Keeping open to going yep, that was how it was doesn’t mean I need to keep doing it in the future. And there may be a better way if I’m open to exploring those. And again, in the Pilates setting one of my mentors, Andrew Cram, used to always say, you know, who do you trust? Do you follow the book or do you follow the bird? I never really understood what he meant. And it’s like, well, if the research says that scratching your left ear is going to release your psoas and someone scratched their left ear and it contracts their psoas. What do you go? Oh, I’m sorry, you’re wrong. The research is right. In the movement, exercise and body based field, we’re always going to follow the body and the clinical assessment. So it’s not to discount what we’re learning from research and evidence, but in the moment, we’re always going to be, going deeply into a clinical assessment. Is this helping? Is it hindering? It doesn’t matter what the research says. If the person in front of me’s body is not responding that way, I’m not going to say we’ll just keep doing it because it’s making you worse, but the research says it’s going to make your back better. we’re going to adapt and follow the body inside us. And that’s, in the Australian culture, especially, but in that Western scientific culture that we have, there’s often a real narrowing down of we can only do what’s evidence based and anything outside that is wrong and it doesn’t exist and there’s no proof. Whereas action research all around the world and embodied personal experience will give you the real, individual research or proof that you need. Does it help? Are you breathing easier? Are you moving more freely? And the trust, like you said, to follow that, to follow your intuition and as a clinician or a Pilates instructor, to follow what you’re seeing in front of you.
Bruce Hildebrand: So great. I was at the Barber myself this morning, Richmond, and waiting in the queue, I thought, I gotta find out about this Barber’s Pole that’s world renowned. The red and white vertical pole that spirals around and basically indicates that the barber is open for service. Do you know the history of the Barber’s Pole yourself, mate?
Richmond Heath: I don’t.
Bruce Hildebrand: Well, In the first instance, a barber used to be the poor person’s dentist and physician for those who couldn’t afford to go to an actual physician. So it was a bit of a, a more kindly somewhat unqualified physician. They would conduct the the dentistry and the surgical requirements as necessary. And a common practice in medicine in the 18th century was to do bloodletting, which you may have heard about. I’ve heard about it in more recent times myself, but a common way to get rid of illnesses and particularly things like pneumonia and uh, Other cardiorespiratory type diseases was to do bloodletting, and the idea was to gently pierce the skin so then blood would be removed and obviously bleed out and be collected and disposed of, and that blood was meant to reduce the volume or intensity of the infection in the body. So that was how it was removed. It’s pretty amazing that you’re talking about this historical accuracy of things that, they quoted in the article, or they read various physicians that were strong believers in those sorts of practices and the efficacy of them. So the red and white of the poll indicates the. gripping onto the pole would be a way to pulsate and basically dilate the blood vessels in the arm, so then the letting could happen. So that was the pole, and then the red indicated the blood and the white indicated the tourniquets that were used to uh, minimise how much blood in total was lost as well. So there’s the red and white barber’s pole origin.
Richmond Heath: So in summary, the origin was that it was a symbol of blood letting. Correct.
Bruce Hildebrand: Correct.
Richmond Heath: I’m not sure I’m going to be able to get my hair cut with as much freedom and relaxation in my body the next time I go to a barber. I’m instantly going to think about, Oh my God, he’s going to get me to squeeze, put a tourniquet on.
Bruce Hildebrand: And interestingly, some of the tools that were used that I saw in this resource that I checked out online didn’t look so dissimilar to what is now used as the shaving device for a beard.
Richmond Heath: Makes sense.
Bruce Hildebrand: Lots of sense. So yeah, it wasn’t so difficult to slice the skin with one of those incredibly sharp razors dentistry as well. that was funniest thing.
Richmond Heath: Yeah. Dentistry. My house is One of my brothers always says, if you think you’re enlightened, visit your dentist or live with your parents for a week. See what happens.
Bruce Hildebrand: I like the letter and Richmond moving on to faux pas number five telling people to control their shaking and tremoring during Pilates. Can you expand on that from your experience with David Berceli and the TRE journey that you’ve had over multiple years now
Richmond Heath: Again, the cultural overlay on shaking and tremoring that I inherited as a physiotherapist, but also in my broader culture was that shaking and tremoring is always a sign of, shock, anxiety. And in the, Pilates or, physical rehab or sports world, it’s a sign of weakness and a lack of control. So stop the exercise and, Move on. Now in one sense that is true, that if I’m trying to create a certain smooth movement, my body’s shaking and trembling, I don’t have that volitional control. And we are at some threshold, but the threshold is that of the limitation of my capacity to cognitively control that movement. And, through that experience I had that I mentioned around the Vipassana meditation, my body starting to spontaneously move and free up in ways that I just thought were almost impossible to go from someone who was in this chronic pain, couldn’t drive a car for more than a couple of hours without spending a day having a live face down on the floor because my back pain. Again, this is over a number of causes, but getting to this point where my body was almost, infinitely flexible and strong and my balance was insane. At some point I I remember walking along a wire, just a normal farm wire fence on a single wire in bare feet, phenomenal. Couldn’t do it today. But this sense of the body having the capacity to do more than I was able to do consciously. And then, without having any understanding for that experience. I knew it was blowing out of the water all the models of strength and everything that I’d inherited, but I didn’t really have anything until many years later, might’ve been eight or 10 years later, a friend gave me a DVD on TRE, which originally stood for trauma release exercises. Now it’s just TRE. It could be trauma resilience. It could be tactile reawakening. It could be time reorientating. It doesn’t really matter, but basically it’s a process where we deliberately. invoke that spontaneous shaking and trembling or movement response. And it comes from, yeah, developed by a guy, Dr. David Berceli, who was a international relief worker and a traumatologist and a psychotherapist who had a background in bioenergetics developed by Alexander Lowen, which also used that shaking and trembling. response and David’s great gift was recognizing that spontaneous shaking and trembling was not a symptom. It wasn’t something, it’s not part of the fight or flight or freeze response because he was seeing in the context of war zones and recognizing it as part of the body’s innate recovery response and a spontaneous subcortical subconscious movement reflex, which is able to organize movement, release tension, deepen our breathing. reset our whole body and organize movement at a level below what we can do consciously. And, then he developed a series of exercises which you don’t even need to use. It’s very simple. It’s just reframing. Again, it’s a key thing. It’s about the faux pas is that most of us without any, there’s no research into shaking and trembling in Pilates, by the way. It’s just a cultural thing because that’s what the teacher told me. That’s what that teacher told me. That’s what that teacher told me. And there’s no research. Whereas if you look around the world, there are cultures all around the world that have been deliberately using the spontaneous shaking and trembling. And then if you’ve got a dog and you see your dog in the thunderstorm starts to shake and tremble, it’s using it. doesn’t care whether there’s double randomized control studies. It just happens because it’s innate to the human organism. And so this is where this shaking and trembling response, we can deliberately use it and integrate it into Pilates so that we’re not only using the top down cognitively directed movement, relaxation, and breath that we all know and love and value in but we can add to that and integrate it with the bottom up Reorganization of movement, breath and relaxation so that we’re able to, you know, I like the term to turbo boost the results. We’re coming at the system from both ways and especially once we start to experience that we can deliberately use this shaking reflex. and we experience the benefits and the freedom and the tension it’s able to let go of that I’m not even aware of is in my body until the body starts to move itself, then it just makes complete sense how again as an example of just reframing this is not shaking trembling it’s not just a sign of weakness it’s not just fatigue or, and so shut it down. And again, I’m not saying always shake because if you just always shake, well your body’s going to do whatever. So it’s about not always telling people to stop and control it. That’s a skill. If you’re doing yoga and you’re shaking and you want to override it, that’s great. It’s strengthening your cortex and your cognitive will. But at the other end of the spectrum is learning how to let go and surrender and allow the body to reorganize itself or lead. And for most of us in the Western world and the Western context, the vast majority of us have problems letting go of control. learning how to surrender, how to soften and relax. And so we can, again, we can integrate the shaking and trembling into our Pilates experience, as well as the control and cognitive direction of movement, relaxation, and breath to get even greater results than if we always tell people that the shaking and trembling is only a sign of weakness, fatigue, or shock, or panic, or anxiety, and we inadvertently shut it down. I describe it’s like, Closing the emergency exit, so we close the capacity for the body to release and downregulate and reorganize and release neuromuscular tension through this natural spontaneous recovery and reorganizational response.
Bruce Hildebrand: What a thorough explanation. I know that there’s a world in that and I know that there’s a hell of a lot more to explore because uh, that’s what it’s going to take. And. Obviously pointing people towards your training and your more recent creation as the founder of the TRE clinical training programs worldwide. the overlay of all this methodology that you’ve accumulated over the years, Richmond, just incredibly valuable for people having, extra layers of breakthroughs in their body and their exploration of movement.
Richmond Heath: totally agree and thank you. And I know you like semantics as much as I do, Bruce. Two weekends ago, we were talking about having a breakthrough and I said, why does it always have to break stuff? Can’t we have a shake through? That’s my new term when we’re doing that. We’re going to have a shake through. What’s that mean? It doesn’t have to be so hard all the time. Sometimes it can. Sometimes it’s great. But yeah, potentials for literally the body shaking things through and releasing stuff and reorganizing ourselves and During COVID, when I couldn’t travel and couldn’t work and I was on JobKeeper, so I wanted to give back something to the money that I was receiving to support me, I created what at the time was the world’s first online TRE course, and that’s been free for the last three years. If you’re listening to this, jump in now, it’s probably hopefully going to go to a contribution based model to keep supporting it. But you can go and learn this technique for yourself. If you just go to, you can either go to treaustralia. com and you’ll find it, or you can go straight to trecourse. com. And that course has got three guided sessions. It’s got background theory, reframing, and it’s got ongoing use advice. It’s got a screening tool if you’ve got any concerns about learning it on your own. So pretty much you can learn the basics and start using that. shaking spontaneous movement response on your own for free for the rest of your life. And that’s my real passion. Is educating people and empowering people to learn how to use this themselves. So you’re not relying upon coming to see me all the time. And then if there are people out there who then want to go, wow, how do I integrate this into Pilates to get even greater results than I’m currently getting? Then I’m excited that in the last. six months or so I’ve started doing a clinical training program. So I’ve been teaching this for 15 years, trained lots of people, but I’m focusing in now on movement exercise and body based professionals because they’ve got that grounding and understanding of the body and movement. And with a little bit of information about how trauma works and works in the body and how it shows up in Pilates in terms of hypotonicity, pain disconnection and altered movement patterns and breathing. With a little bit of information about that, then it’s very simple. And I find it really profound to empower, Pilates instructors and physios with the knowledge and skills, and it doesn’t take much to then be able to integrate that into their clinical practice. So they can then empower other people With the skills again, it doesn’t replace anything that we already know it enhances and builds upon. And it gives people a simple but profound tool for healing and reorganization and development, not just in the neuromuscular setting, but in our whole, life and our organism to support ongoing healing and growth.
Bruce Hildebrand: thanks for your wonderful contribution to that free online training with tracourse. com. Highly recommend you go and check it out. The explanations I’ve been around for a long time with Richmond and they make complete sense and a lot of new distinctions that I took away from many workshops with you Richmond over the years. So thanks a lot.
Richmond Heath: You’re very welcome. And again I’m, passing on what I inherited from David Berceli, who, flipped this whole story in its head. And again, this is so I’m developing and expanding and just giving different perspectives on work that he passed on to me and I’m passing on to others who will pass it on. As well, and there are TRE practitioners in about 80 countries around the world. So this is literally a grassroots movement, literally a spontaneous movement that’s rippling through the world. And again, TREs, it’s just a modern Western neuroscientific trauma informed model or language or perspective that fits our culture and our scientific understanding. But at the same time, recognizing that traditional cultures around the world have been using this for thousands of years, you know, the Kalahari Bushmen call themselves the keepers of the shape, the ancient samurai practice something called Seikijutsu, where they would meditate their body into spontaneous movements, the Swahili, So in the Swahili culture, traditional midwives will deliberately keep women standing after birth to help facilitate that woman’s body to shake and tremble, sometimes for up to half an hour, because they’ve observed in themselves and in animals that if we don’t let that discharge happen and all that shake and get rid of all the stress and trauma, the woman will have difficulties after birth. So in a sense, TREs, the latest Western interpretation of this phenomenon that’s common to all mammals, all humans, and has been described in other great books. Shaking Medicine by Bradford Keeney is described as the oldest medicine on earth because it’s something that was innate inside us and that cultures for thousands and thousands of decades of years have been deliberately using for their health, being, spirituality, relational health, connection to themselves, to others in the world around them.
Bruce Hildebrand: Amazing. And The workshop that you’re delivering upcoming is differentiating the breath and owning the diaphragm in Pilates. Can you tell us more about that?
Richmond Heath: Well, What I can tell you is I would like to run that workshop. I haven’t got it set up per se. And so we would be pretty much exploring those first couple of faux pas around breathing it out in certain directions in movement and giving people a little bit of embodied experience of playing with that so that we can really make a key concept is freeing up the diaphragm for breath and getting the movement in other areas. So my plan, Bruce, is to run a Probably an online workshop at some point. I don’t have anything set up, but if you’re a listener and you’re interested and you think, gee, that sounds great. I’d like to explore that. I’m imagining it’s like a 2 or 3 hour class. Because again, it’s not about me then teaching you whole Pilates repertoire and doing that, but just giving you a couple of simple concepts and a few simple experiences so you can make sense of it and integrate that understanding and knowledge. So then you can apply it to your Pilates practice, both personally and professionally. So if you’re interested in something like that, please get in touch with me. Easiest way to get in contact with me is via the TRE Australia website. So that’s just treaustralia. com. And yeah, I’m keen to share this and create a little online workshop space for Pilates instructors. So if you’re interested, get in touch. And if I get enough people who are interested, then I’ll put something on and send you the details.
Bruce Hildebrand: I can see a workshop on the horizon for you, Richmond, differentiating the breath and owning the diaphragm in Pilates. Looks like something like that might be in the wings for you.
Richmond Heath: Yeah, I’m very excited to share some of that. And I would love to be doing some in person as well, but at this stage, I think the information and the experience we can easily do online and it makes it accessible to people. So stay tuned.
Bruce Hildebrand: As always, Richmond, wonderful chatting with you on the Pilates Diaries podcast. Thanks so much for your time and generosity coming onto this episode. you’ve mentioned where people can get in contact with you through the treaustralia. com website. Check it out. Check out the other links that we’ve talked about on this episode. And as always, thanks so much for tuning in for the Pilates Diaries podcast. Thank you again, Richmond.
Richmond Heath: Thanks, Bruce. And thanks to the listeners. Hopefully this has been inspiring and useful for you and just wish you all well in your personal and professional practices of Pilates.
Bruce Hildebrand: My thanks to Richmond for such an open conversation. Before you go, one more mention of Trimio, my own startup, so you know where I stand. If you run a studio with downtime in the timetable, trimio.app/host. If you teach and want more hours in your week, trimio.app/offer. And if you’d just like your teacher closer to home, tell them about it, trimio.app. There’s a gap. Trimio’s built to close it. The Pilates Diaries podcast lives at thepilatesdiariespodcast.com. Follow the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen, so the next peek into a guest’s Pilates diary finds you. I’m Bruce Hildebrand. Thanks for listening.